September 26, 2025

Reliance on hearsay, breadth of order lead BC Court of Appeal to deny ministry’s request for a permanent injunction

British Columbia (Ministry of Social Development and Poverty Reduction) v Choquette, 2025 BCCA 333, involved an appeal by the ministry from a chambers judge’s decision to reject a claim for a permanent injunction. The appeal largely turned on the application of section 42 of the Evidence Act—which sets out the Read more

July 21, 2025

BC Court of Appeal declines to allow colour-of-right defence based on Indigenous laws

R v Cavanaugh, 2025 BCCA 252, was an appeal from several convictions for criminal contempt. The convictions involved interfering with a Trans Mountain pipeline site in breach of an injunction. “The primary issue on appeal”, the court noted, was “whether the judge failed to take Indigenous laws into account when Read more

July 4, 2025

BC Supreme Court denies anticipatory injunction in racetrack dispute

Harness Racing B.C. Society v Orangeville Raceway Limited, 2025 BCSC 1249—a recent decision of the BC Supreme Court—was a dispute between the owners of a horse-racing facility (the defendants) and a society and its members (the plaintiffs), who were among the main users of the racetrack facility. The dispute turned Read more